You must be a subscriber to view the main content of this page. Please subscribe to an option that fits your needs and get access to core content! If you are already a subscriber just sign in below. If you have purchased a subscription via Offline payment, the content will be unlocked upon receiving your payment.
The Execution of Bin Laden in Images
Doi: https://doi.org/10.47659/m3.098.art
- Vol. 2, no. 2
- 2017
- June 5, 2020
The photo essay illustrates the politics of missing visuals from the public domain and analysis of the artist’s book Bin Laden Situation Room. The book is a reaction to the photograph issued on 2 May 2011 by the American government at the time of Bin Laden’s execution. The image taken by the official White House photographer Pete Souza, depicts president Barack Obama and his national security team witnessing the execution of Osama Bin Laden, the leader of the Islamic militant organization, al-Qaeda. Apart from this the American government did not issue any other visual evidence of the event. The essay explores war strategies of keeping the visuals mute, and in doing so, controlling the public opinion. Photography that prides itself on representing and uncovering historical moments, completely fails here. The book Bin Laden Situation Room, attempts to look for what the image fails to show. The essay examines the visibility and invisibility of frames of references and power to see and not see.
- Keywords: Bin Laden, missing images, photo book, photography, situation room
Chinar Shah is an artist teaching at Srishti Institute of Art, Design and Technology, Bangalore, where she is also a coordinator for photography discipline. Chinar did her M.A. in Literature and MFA/PGDP in Photography from NID, Ahmedabad, India. She has shown her work both in India and abroad. Some of her recent works were shown in Tate Liverpool, Birmingham Photo Festival, and Art Bengaluru and in “Material Light” – a collateral exhibition at Kochi Biennale. She is a co-editor of Photography in India: From Archives to Contemporary Practice, (Bloomsbury forthcoming). Chinar recently received the prestigious Inlaks Shivdasani Foundation grant to complete a long-standing project The Real Taste of India.
- Campbell, D., 2001. US Buys Up All Satellite War Images. In: The Guardian, [online]. Available online here. [2.10.2017].
- Campbell, D., 2001. Deconstructing the Situation Room. Available online here. [2.10.2017].
- Didi-Huberman, G., 2003. Images in Spite of All: Four Photographs from Auschwitz. In: Stallabrass J. (eds.), Documentary. London: Whitechapel Gallery Ventures Limited; MA: The MIT Press, pp.152–154. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8357.2010.01082.x
- Goodman Gallery, 2016. Alfredo Jaar / Amilcar, Frantz, Patrice and the others. Curatorial text, Johannesburg. Available online here. [1.10.2017].
- Johnson, K., 2011. Situation: Ambiguous. In: The New York Times, [online]. Available online here. [2.10.2017].
- Kennedy, L., 2012. Seeing and Believing: On Photography and the War on Terror. In: Public Culture (Vol. 24), Spring. NC.: Duke University Press, pp.261–282. https://doi.org/10.1215/08992363-1535498
- Macqueen, K., 2013. The Strength to See. In: Flash Art, [online]. Available online here. [2.10.2017].
- Reading, A., 2014. The Journalist as Memory Assembler: Non-Memory, the War on Terror and the Shooting of Osama Bin Laden. In: B. Zelizer & K. Tenenboim-Weinblatt, eds. Journalism and Memory. UK: Palgrave Macmillan Memory Studies, pp.164–178. https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137263940_11
- Silverleib, A., 2011. Obama on Sunday: A photo for the ages? In: CNN Politics, [online]. Available online here. [30.9.2017].
Abstract
Author
References
Artists
PDF
Close
The photo essay illustrates the politics of missing visuals from the public domain and analysis of the artist’s book Bin Laden Situation Room. The book is a reaction to the photograph issued on 2 May 2011 by the American government at the time of Bin Laden’s execution. The image taken by the official White House photographer Pete Souza, depicts president Barack Obama and his national security team witnessing the execution of Osama Bin Laden, the leader of the Islamic militant organization, al-Qaeda. Apart from this the American government did not issue any other visual evidence of the event. The essay explores war strategies of keeping the visuals mute, and in doing so, controlling the public opinion. Photography that prides itself on representing and uncovering historical moments, completely fails here. The book Bin Laden Situation Room, attempts to look for what the image fails to show. The essay examines the visibility and invisibility of frames of references and power to see and not see.
- Keywords: Bin Laden, missing images, photo book, photography, situation room
Chinar Shah is an artist teaching at Srishti Institute of Art, Design and Technology, Bangalore, where she is also a coordinator for photography discipline. Chinar did her M.A. in Literature and MFA/PGDP in Photography from NID, Ahmedabad, India. She has shown her work both in India and abroad. Some of her recent works were shown in Tate Liverpool, Birmingham Photo Festival, and Art Bengaluru and in “Material Light” – a collateral exhibition at Kochi Biennale. She is a co-editor of Photography in India: From Archives to Contemporary Practice, (Bloomsbury forthcoming). Chinar recently received the prestigious Inlaks Shivdasani Foundation grant to complete a long-standing project The Real Taste of India.
- Campbell, D., 2001. US Buys Up All Satellite War Images. In: The Guardian, [online]. Available online here. [2.10.2017].
- Campbell, D., 2001. Deconstructing the Situation Room. Available online here. [2.10.2017].
- Didi-Huberman, G., 2003. Images in Spite of All: Four Photographs from Auschwitz. In: Stallabrass J. (eds.), Documentary. London: Whitechapel Gallery Ventures Limited; MA: The MIT Press, pp.152–154. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8357.2010.01082.x
- Goodman Gallery, 2016. Alfredo Jaar / Amilcar, Frantz, Patrice and the others. Curatorial text, Johannesburg. Available online here. [1.10.2017].
- Johnson, K., 2011. Situation: Ambiguous. In: The New York Times, [online]. Available online here. [2.10.2017].
- Kennedy, L., 2012. Seeing and Believing: On Photography and the War on Terror. In: Public Culture (Vol. 24), Spring. NC.: Duke University Press, pp.261–282. https://doi.org/10.1215/08992363-1535498
- Macqueen, K., 2013. The Strength to See. In: Flash Art, [online]. Available online here. [2.10.2017].
- Reading, A., 2014. The Journalist as Memory Assembler: Non-Memory, the War on Terror and the Shooting of Osama Bin Laden. In: B. Zelizer & K. Tenenboim-Weinblatt, eds. Journalism and Memory. UK: Palgrave Macmillan Memory Studies, pp.164–178. https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137263940_11
- Silverleib, A., 2011. Obama on Sunday: A photo for the ages? In: CNN Politics, [online]. Available online here. [30.9.2017].
Abstract
Author
References
Artists
PDF
Close
The photo essay illustrates the politics of missing visuals from the public domain and analysis of the artist’s book Bin Laden Situation Room. The book is a reaction to the photograph issued on 2 May 2011 by the American government at the time of Bin Laden’s execution. The image taken by the official White House photographer Pete Souza, depicts president Barack Obama and his national security team witnessing the execution of Osama Bin Laden, the leader of the Islamic militant organization, al-Qaeda. Apart from this the American government did not issue any other visual evidence of the event. The essay explores war strategies of keeping the visuals mute, and in doing so, controlling the public opinion. Photography that prides itself on representing and uncovering historical moments, completely fails here. The book Bin Laden Situation Room, attempts to look for what the image fails to show. The essay examines the visibility and invisibility of frames of references and power to see and not see.
- Keywords: Bin Laden, missing images, photo book, photography, situation room
Chinar Shah is an artist teaching at Srishti Institute of Art, Design and Technology, Bangalore, where she is also a coordinator for photography discipline. Chinar did her M.A. in Literature and MFA/PGDP in Photography from NID, Ahmedabad, India. She has shown her work both in India and abroad. Some of her recent works were shown in Tate Liverpool, Birmingham Photo Festival, and Art Bengaluru and in “Material Light” – a collateral exhibition at Kochi Biennale. She is a co-editor of Photography in India: From Archives to Contemporary Practice, (Bloomsbury forthcoming). Chinar recently received the prestigious Inlaks Shivdasani Foundation grant to complete a long-standing project The Real Taste of India.
- Campbell, D., 2001. US Buys Up All Satellite War Images. In: The Guardian, [online]. Available online here. [2.10.2017].
- Campbell, D., 2001. Deconstructing the Situation Room. Available online here. [2.10.2017].
- Didi-Huberman, G., 2003. Images in Spite of All: Four Photographs from Auschwitz. In: Stallabrass J. (eds.), Documentary. London: Whitechapel Gallery Ventures Limited; MA: The MIT Press, pp.152–154. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8357.2010.01082.x
- Goodman Gallery, 2016. Alfredo Jaar / Amilcar, Frantz, Patrice and the others. Curatorial text, Johannesburg. Available online here. [1.10.2017].
- Johnson, K., 2011. Situation: Ambiguous. In: The New York Times, [online]. Available online here. [2.10.2017].
- Kennedy, L., 2012. Seeing and Believing: On Photography and the War on Terror. In: Public Culture (Vol. 24), Spring. NC.: Duke University Press, pp.261–282. https://doi.org/10.1215/08992363-1535498
- Macqueen, K., 2013. The Strength to See. In: Flash Art, [online]. Available online here. [2.10.2017].
- Reading, A., 2014. The Journalist as Memory Assembler: Non-Memory, the War on Terror and the Shooting of Osama Bin Laden. In: B. Zelizer & K. Tenenboim-Weinblatt, eds. Journalism and Memory. UK: Palgrave Macmillan Memory Studies, pp.164–178. https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137263940_11
- Silverleib, A., 2011. Obama on Sunday: A photo for the ages? In: CNN Politics, [online]. Available online here. [30.9.2017].
- Cover photo: Chinar Shah: The Execution of Bin Laden in Images. Courtesy of Pete Souza.
It was with the tools of obliteration that archives – the memory of the obliteration – had to be obliterated. It was a way of keeping the obliteration forever in its unimaginable condition.
– Georges Didi-Huberman
Reading Time: 8 minutes
Reading Time: 8 minutes
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
- Cover photo: Chinar Shah: The Execution of Bin Laden in Images. Courtesy of Pete Souza.
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin